This is the inside story of a 20-year Civil War inside MCC over the future of Lord’s about which the 18,000 membership have been kept in the dark throughout.
On the one side is the MCC establishment, the epitome of a self-perpetuating old boy network but with a global brand name . On the other is a formidable self-made property developer Charles Rifkind who wanted to change the face of Lord’s and had the blueprint to do so.
Rifkind had bought the rights to develop the railway tunnels under the Nursery End – on the boundary of the most famous cricket ground in the world – from under the noses of the MCC.
This audacious auction success led to two decades of frustration for Rifkind as MCC rebuffed his every attempt to develop the ground in a Vision for Lord’s that could have been worth £450 million between them.
It is a saga that saw MCC’s great and the good taking sides in an increasingly acrimonious conflict played out in furious debates behind the closed Grace Gates.
The cast list includes a former Prime Minister in Sir John Major plus household names from cricket lincluding England Test captains David Gower, Mike Brearley, Mike Gatting and Michael Atherton – along with a cameo role from Wimbledon champion Boris Becker.
There are captains of finance and industry and a stellar ‘A’ list of lawyers, architects , property consultants and developers . Plus the embattled Lord’s secretariat and dedicated activists and agitators amongst the MCC membership.
An epic struggle between the guardians of 234 years of tradition at Lord’s and a new order intent on change is told through documents, minutes and personal accounts that delve under the covers of Lord’s and MCC like never before.
From the Foreword by Matthew Engel:
Essentially, it (the story) involves a collision between an unstoppable force and an immovable object. On the one side, the property developer Charles Rifkind, obsessive, implacable, annoying. On the other, the Marylebone Cricket Club, traditionalist, in many ways offering magnificent stewardship of the game it practically invented, in other ways dysfunctional. Neither is above a bit of vengefulness. Beneath their feet: the railway tunnels, forlorn, disused, surprisingly spacious. In the dying days of the twentieth century they were sold off. MCC had every chance to buy them but dithered.
Charles Sale worked as a sports journalist for 40 years . Starting on the Acton Gazette in West London in 1978 , he progressed via the Northern Echo in Darlington to the Daily Express in 1983 and then to the Daily Mail in 2001.
He wrote a daily column Sports Agenda throughout his time on the Mail before retiring in 2018. The column delved behind the scenes at all the major sports and always held to account the main sporting bodies including the MCC.
His one claim to cricketing fame is playing what is reportedly a world record for the slowest innings of all time. Batting for Repton School against Malvern in 1974, he scored 1 not out in 2hr 32minutes over 58 overs to salvage a draw. The one run came off the first ball , an inside edge that narrowly missed the stumps.
Work on The Covers are Off which started in earnest in April 2019 has taken longer than the building of the Compton & Edrich Stands but both projects have happily come to fruition at the start of the summer of 2021.
This is his second book on cricket. The first one published in 1984 , ‘Korty the Legend Explained’ told the story of Essex bowler Charles Kortright , acknowledged as the fastest of them all during the Golden Age of cricket before the First World War.
Pre-order paperback, hardback or ebook from Amazon
Or paperback from Wisden.com
And some archive footage from Channel 4
A fabulous review in www.acscricket.com but the piece is not yet up. Here are a couple of snippets:
Riveting! How often does one say that of a cricket
book? Yet now it is my verdict on a book that, I fear, all too few will choose
to read. To members of MCC, of whom I admit to being one, it should be a ‘must
read’, but to the rest of the cricket-loving world how interesting are the
club’s internecine wars? The Lord’s shop ought to stock the book, but I guess
it may be forbidden to do so!
Sale has been busy with his recording machine.
Though several with important roles turned him down, the leading players on
both sides of the internal and external squabbles have mostly been glad to talk
freely, while there is an impressive use of email trails, verbatim transcripts
of meetings and minutes that MCC usually like to keep away from prying eyes for
decades. One guesses that there has been a helpful mole or two giving access to
restricted papers – it is that sort of book and all the more readable for
Fascinating Q&A with Charles Sale
And a great podcast on The Unofficial Partner
What a great and accurate description from Paddy Briggs: It is a very English scandal which has all the usual English disease elements in it. Too much Pride. Too much Prejudice. Too much snobbery. Too much mendacity. Too much downright incompetence. Charles Sale really does tell the story well. Essential reading for MCC members, cricket lovers and those who study the English psyche.
A lovely review in CricInfo here
And some snippets from the universally positive reviews in the top media.
If you want a summary of the saga, imagine a fracas in St John’s Wood High Street featuring a lot of braying, blazered old men interspersed with cries of “He’s not worth it , Tarquin.”
But so well researched is Charles Sale’s book, so broad the range of interviews and so remarkable his access to source material, that this is, against all the odds, a compelling read.
George Dobell, ESPN cricinfo
Charles Sale’s book is scalpel-sharp investigative journalism told with a ringing clarity. It is the story itself that will madden and frustrate -that is when you are not laughing blackly or bleakly at how closely it veers towards a satirical or parody of a particular kind of Englishness. It’s very much a Kingsley Amiss sort of narrative.
Sale is a natural investigator with an ear for dialogue. Much of the story unfolds in the words of others, a decision which allows the complexity of it to breath.
Jon Hotten, Wisden Cricket Monthly
Those who know Charlie Sale only through his sports diary in the Daily Mail, which was never other than aggressive commentary, might be surprised by its balanced approach.
Sale assesses the evidence and all the minutes he has uncovered and comes to a conclusion as to whether , to quote Monty Python on MCC, Charles Rifkind was ‘slit up a treat.’This is a terrific book.
Ivo Tennant, The Cricketer
It is a very English scandal which has all the usual English disease elements in. It. Too much pride.Too much prejudice. Too much snobbery. Too much mendacity. Too much down right incompetence. Charles Sale really does tell the story well.
Essential reading for MCC members, cricket lovers and those who study the English psyche.
Paddy Briggs , cricket journalist.
Riveting. How often does one say that of a cricket book ?
The story that Charles Sale tells exposes two opposing cultures and rather different priorities.
It is against this background that Sale traces in forensic and sometimes brutal detail every step of a saga that has dragged on for over 20 years.
Sale has been busy with his recording machine. One guesses that there has been a helpful mole or two giving access to restricted papers . It is that sort of book and all the more readable for it.
Douglas Miller, Association of Cricket Statisticians and Historians